The second extension of Caldwell's original Blind Man's Bluff cigar, following the 2017 release of a Connecticut version, the Blind Man's Bluff Maduro cigar debuted in 2019. Unlike those first two versions, the Maduro showcases an entirely different blend, comprising a Sumatran binder and fillers from the Dominican Republic all in a Pennsylvania Maduro wrapper. Hand-rolled at the William Ventura factory in the Dominican Republic, the Blind Man's Bluff Maduro offers notes of wood, earth, and pepper.